David said:
Both ideas sound ludicrous.
Have any of your "friends" tried either of these gimmicks?.....and lived to talk about it?
The physics is sound on both counts, but in option A, depending on how severe the dent is: are you sure an air compressor (~120 psi) is enough force to push out the dent without pushing anything else out of alignment?
What about the residual vapour left in the tank?
I'm really posing a question here: does anyone else see warning signs when mixing compressed air and fuel vapour?
Option B the expansion of the freezing water will push out with force in all directions. Not just the targeted area. The expansion will most distort the weakest parts of the tank, and that may not necessarily be the dent. Youre bang on that if you dont stop the process in time it will pop a seam like a beer can left in the freezer too long.
Cool yer britches David. I'm not trying to get anyone killed here. I did say that these were some crazy ideas however the theory and I mean "theory" is there.
The metal at the site of the dent has weakened compared to the rest of the tank. When the pressure is induced, that then pressure will find the weak point in the metal and cause it to reshape,popout. In Theory.
As far as using compressed air nobody said to introduce 120psi into the tank. That's just plain idiotic. Where I work I offload railcars and tanker trailers full of dangerous chemical and we never use more than 20 psi into a vessel. Also as far as the fuel/ air mixture concern.. There are ways to get by that. 1. Drain all gas out of tank and let the tank sit open to evaporate remaining gas fumes. (that part may take awhile). 2. Don't smoke while your doing it. 3. Be in a very well ventilated area (like a military missile testing site). 4. Wear a suit like someone who works for the bomb squad. From what I heard is that minimal psi is needed to achieve this and if the air was Slowly introduced into the tank then risk could be kept at minimal.
As far as the freezing tank idea... I've heard of this a couple of times. Some old Harely guys said thats how they popped out dents back in the 50's and 60's. It was a cheap way to fix a tank without taking it to someone fix or buying a new tank. Another buddy bought an original W.W.II OD green jerry gas can for his Jeep. It had a dent on one of the flat sides (bout size of a quarter). He said that was how he fixed the dent on the can. He filled it with water. Stuck it in a freezer and popped most of the dent. You can still see it a little but for the most part it can do it. However if the tank has a weaker point such as a weld seam, it will burst the tank and that would be no good.